top 9, america! :) here are my two cents:
anoop - caught up: usher's da man, so anoop definitely picked big shoes. he's doing all right with it. his pitch isn't perfect, but it's made worse by the backups. i don't know what it is with the backing vocals this year, but i've had issues with it al season. but as far as anoop... i wish the song was more upbeat. though the tune itself is higher energy, it only works with a bunch of dancing... randy agrees. overall, i still like him.
**side note: i love when simon puts in a huge insult and then adds "if you want my honest opinion". haha oh, simon. as if we had a choice.
megan - turn your lights down low: this girl is really pretty. i can't make up my mind about her. i definitely hear how her voice is different, with this old-school cabaret flavor. and i like that. but sometimes her stage presence and vocal-isms are so awkward that i can't tell if she's good or not. the judges are being pretty hard on her. it's like paula said, "okay, she gets it".
**side note: the judges take a super-long time with the singers in the beginning, and then at the end they have to be like, "i loved it, you're pretty, go". lol
danny gokey - what hurts the most: oh, no. i love this song so much and it's gonna get gokey'd. dang. okay, i'm gonna try to be objective and listen. :)... nope, can't. hate it. kidding. but i wish he would utilize more straight tones, which gary from the rascal flatts most definitely does. and danny's voice is so scratchy. maybe he has nodules on his vocal chords... will the judges rave? yup. maybe i need to read a book about it or something. but i'm just not getting it.
allison - don't speak: man, i really dislike those backup singers. it's hard, 'cause i love that she has a more "weathered" rock sound, but that's not gwen. gwen has this masterful way of being soft and hard in a tune, playing a little girl voice versus a soulful rockin' voice, and i love that dynamic. but is it fair to compare allison's vocal to that? either way, i still think she's
scott - just he way you are: this guy is super sweet. i still think he's a little out of his element vocally, but i can hardly help but root for him. however, when paula was critiquing, she said something about how "it has nothing to do with your challenge" and simon made a face (without meaning to) that showed he disagreed. 'cause let's be honest, that does help him with votes. but i think he did a good job this week, and definitely good enough to go on to next week.
matt - you found me: i hope he uses straight tones; this could be a lot like when he sang coldplay... it sounds like he's really trying to. yeah, i like that he seems to be trying new stuff with his voice. i feel like he didn't just do what he has always done this week. he pushed himself. paula thinks it sounds like coldplay... and i completely disagree. i think it's very unlike when he sang coldplay. all the judges agree... i don't get it... randy says he should do stuff with "more riffs". okay, for once i agree with kara. she said he's not deciding one side or the other "pop-rock" or "pop-rnb". and i get that. i get what they're saying. but i still think he's good. in my top 5 still.
lil rounds - surrender: i don't think i'm going to like this. her pitch is not really as on point as you need it to be for this tune. celine dion is definitely in great pitch all the time. the second half was good, though. i still like her, and want her to do well. and daaaaang, her kids are cute! :)
**side note: an ad for prince's new albums; man, that guy is king. haha i typed that without even realizing it.
adam - play that funky music: even the pre-video shows him screaming. i don't think i should be allowed to critique this guy anymore. he makes me feel like mothers must've felt about elvis when he came on the scene. i feel like everything adam sings/does has all these sexual undertones. and that his vocals are super self-indulgent. DO NOT compare this guy to mick jagger and steve tyler. steve tyler is an artist, and i don't think that of adam. anyone who has chatted with me about adam outside of my blogs knows i have made that EXACT distinction before.
kris - ain't no sunshine: i like the quartet. and i like his performance. his pitch is great, his tone is great, and now we know he plays piano well enough. :) i'm a big kris fan.
bottom three: anoop, megan, and scott. i think it's possible matt will end up down there instead of megan, but that anoop with go home. we'll see tomorrow night!! ;)